Fiction Writing Made Easy with Savannah Gilbo | How to Write a Novel & Writing Advice
Do you have a story you can't stop thinking about? Maybe it's still just an idea. Maybe it's half a draft you haven't opened in months, or a finished manuscript that doesn't quite work yet. Wherever you are, it can be hard to know what your story needs next.
Fiction Writing Made Easy is a podcast for aspiring fiction authors who want clear, practical guidance on what to do next with their novels. Hosted by developmental editor and book coach Savannah Gilbo, the show breaks down complicated writing concepts into simple, actionable lessons. Savannah explains why storytelling techniques work, how the different elements of a story fit together, and what that means for your own writing—often using examples from familiar books and movies.
Topics include developing your story idea, outlining a novel, creating characters readers care about, writing scenes that move your story forward, and figuring out what to fix when your draft isn't working. You'll also find genre deep dives on romance, fantasy, thrillers, and horror, mindset tips for difficult writing days, and advice on querying agents and self-publishing.
You'll also hear from editors and industry experts, as well as writers Savannah has taught who share how they finished—and often published—their books. With hundreds of episodes and over 3.8 million downloads, there's plenty to explore wherever you are with your book.
Hit follow for new episodes every week—and take the next step toward a novel you're proud of.
Fiction Writing Made Easy with Savannah Gilbo | How to Write a Novel & Writing Advice
#269. Multiple Antagonists: How to Make Them Work in Your Novel
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Can your novel have more than one antagonist? Absolutely! But if several characters are creating conflict for your protagonist, how do you know which one is the main antagonist? And how do you make sure all those different characters and conflicts contribute to one cohesive story?
In this episode, I'll explain how main and secondary antagonists work, why they don't all need the same amount of development or page time, and three things to consider when writing a novel with multiple antagonists. You'll learn how to make these characters work together without letting your story go in a dozen different directions.
〰️
In This Episode:
[02:02] Antagonist vs. conflict: What's the difference?
[08:17] How to identify your main antagonist
[13:36] What Harry Potter teaches us about secondary antagonists
[16:37] When to combine antagonists into one character
[17:13] How secondary conflicts develop and resolve
〰️
Links Mentioned:
5 Questions To Write Better Antagonists
〰️
Other Episodes You'll Love:
How to Figure Out the Shape of Your Story
Red Herrings: How to Mislead & Surprise Readers
How to Start Planning Your Book Series
〰️
If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a review and follow the show! Your support helps this podcast reach more writers who need these actionable tips and insights.
〰️
More Resources:
Live Training: Learn why you keep getting stuck and how to finally finish your novel.
Revision Accelerator: Identify your draft's biggest problems and make a plan to fix them.
Podcast Playlist: Get 10 episodes to help you reach your next big writing goal.
〰️
Follow for more writing tips: Instagram | savannahgilbo.com
The purpose of having multiple antagonists isn't just to give your protagonists more problems to deal with. I mean, sometimes that's how it starts. But the actual purpose is to create different kinds of conflict and opposition that help your character grow and change and that add something meaningful to the bigger story that you're telling. Welcome to the Fiction Writing Made Easy Podcast. My name is Savannah Gilbo, and I'm here to help you write a story that works. I want to prove to you that writing a novel doesn't have to be overwhelming. So each week I'll bring you a brand new episode with simple, actionable, and step-by-step strategies that you can implement in your writing right away. So whether you're brand new to writing or more of a seasoned author looking to improve your craft, this podcast is for you. So pick up a pen and let's get started. In today's episode, we're talking about how to write a story with multiple antagonists. And I've been wanting to record this episode for a long time because one of the most common questions I get asked is, can I write a story with more than one antagonist? And if so, how do I know who the main antagonist is if there are more than one? And speaking of that, what about things like a hurricane? Does that count as an antagonist? What about my character's grief or their self-loathing? How does that factor into things and can that be my antagonist? So I get questions like these all the time. And of course, there are so many things to think about when it comes to writing a story in general, but even more when it comes to writing a story with more than one antagonist. And so if you've ever wondered any of these questions, then you are in good company because, like I said, they are so very common. And so in this episode, I'm going to walk you through what actually counts as an antagonist and what is simply just conflict. We're going to talk about how to tell who your main antagonist is if you do have multiple antagonists. And then I'm also going to share three things to keep in mind as you outline and write your story if you are writing a story with more than one antagonist. So, with all of that being said, let's go ahead and dive right into the episode, starting with the very first question we need to ask, which is what is the difference between antagonism and conflict?
Antagonist vs. Conflict: What’s the Difference?
SPEAKER_00And I want to start with conflict. So, conflict, you probably already know this already, but just in case, conflict is anything that makes it harder for your protagonist to get what they want. And antagonists can be one source of that conflict, right? An antagonist for sure makes it hard for a protagonist to get what they want. So they are one source of conflict, but they are not the only source of conflict. Because conflict can also come from things like your story setting, so the physical world that your story takes place in, including the weather and mother nature. Conflict can also come from society, so things like the rules of society, the expectations of society, and even the institutions that exist in your society that your characters live in and under. Conflict can also come from situations and circumstances. So these are things like events that your protagonist didn't choose, like maybe an accident, an illness, or some kind of deadline. And then, of course, conflict can come from internal obstacles as well. So things like your protagonist's flaws, their fears, and their misbeliefs. All right, so conflict can come from a lot of different places, and one of those places is from your antagonist. So speaking of antagonists, let's get on the same page about what an antagonistic character really is. And really, this is just someone who opposes your protagonist. Now, I just said they're someone who opposes your protagonist, right? So there's someone who has agency, meaning they want something, they have reasons for wanting that something, and they make choices and take actions to get that thing. All right, so it is someone who opposes your protagonist that has agency. So what I want you to notice here is that again, conflict can come from a whole lot of different places. And just to list them again, I said conflict can come from your antagonist, come from the setting, society, situations and circumstances, and internal obstacles. Now, as an example, I want you to think about Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, right? In that story, there is a lot of stuff that causes conflict. There's a forbidden forest that is off limits to the students and is full of magical and dangerous beasts. Hogwarts itself has rules, so the third floor corridor is off limits. Kids need to be in bed by a certain hour, they can't go certain places when they're not supposed to, you know, other things like that. And then Harry has his own internal conflict and insecurities that create conflict as well. Okay, so all of that creates conflict for Harry and the other characters to deal with. But characters like Voldemort, Malfoy, Snape, and even the Dursleys, they are antagonists because they have their own goals and they make choices that interfere with Harry's life. So they are antagonists that cause conflict, but Harry's insecurities or the Forbidden Forest or the Hogwarts school rules, those are simply sources of conflict and they don't count as a source of antagonism. All right, so you might be like, Savannah, you've said the same thing like four times. Why does this distinction matter? Well, it matters because creating conflict and developing an antagonist aren't quite the same job. And a lot of writers will get hung up on this because they'll say things like, Savannah, I have plenty of conflict in my story. I can't tell why it's not working. And I say, okay, who is your main antagonist? And they'll say something like, Well, my protagonist is dealing with grief and they have a lot of self-doubt about their new career, and you know, society's really holding them back from doing what they want. And I'm like, okay, great, those are all really good sources of conflict, but who is your main antagonist? And in a lot of cases, the writers who bring these kind of problems to me will be like, I guess I don't have one. And that is why their stories don't work, right? So that is why I'm being a little repetitive here because I really want to make sure we understand the difference between conflict and an antagonist or a source of antagonism. And that really comes down to agency and opposition. And so just to kind of be super clear about what I mean, something like a storm can strand your protagonist in the wilderness. That will create a bunch of conflict for your character. But a storm doesn't need a motivation or a plan. It just kind of functions as a storm or any other force of nature would, right? And because of that, it can only cause so much conflict, usually conflict of the same nature and intensity as well, for your protagonist to face. But something like a rival character, on the other hand, needs a reason to stand in your protagonist's way, because otherwise it's just not going to make sense, right? And they need to be someone who has the ability to make choices and take actions that complicate things. So that's that source of agency I was talking about earlier. And again, this distinction and knowing the difference helps you figure out how much development work to do, how to prioritize things in your draft, and things like that. All right. So again, I know that I just went over that a few different times, but it's probably one of the most important distinctions that I'll talk about on this podcast because again, I see a lot of writers who think that they have conflict and that the conflict does the job of an antagonist, but that is not true. Okay, so that is the difference between conflict or something that is simply just conflict versus an antagonist that creates conflict. And if this just felt like a light bulb turning on for you, then your very first step after listening to this episode is to separate out the antagonists, or if you have more than one, the multiple antagonists, separate them out from your sources of conflict and just get clear on do you have both or do you only have conflict and do you still need to work on your antagonist? And then once
Establishing Your Antagonist Hierarchy
SPEAKER_00you've identified the antagonists or antagonists in your story, the next question you're gonna face or think about is what role does each one play or what do they actually do, right? And who is driving the central conflict in your story? And how do you keep the other antagonists from pulling your story in too many directions, right? So what I advise my students in my notes to novel course is to create something that I call your antagonist hierarchy. And this is really just a simple way to think about the different layers of conflict from antagonists and the different roles that your antagonist will play in the story. So at the top of this hierarchy, you're gonna have your main antagonist. And this is the character whose goals and actions are central to your story's main conflict. Okay, so they are responsible for your story's central or main conflict. And then underneath that, in the rest of your hierarchy, are gonna be your secondary or lesser antagonists. So these are people who create additional conflict and complications for your protagonist, but they aren't the main antagonist, or they're not necessarily responsible for your story's main central conflict. This doesn't mean that they are not important, they just play a different role. Okay. So we want to create your hierarchy and figure out who sits at the top because that is your main antagonist. Now, as an example, think about Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone again. So at the top of the hierarchy, we have Voldemort. He's the main antagonist, and he has a plan to steal the sorcerer's stone, and that plan drives the central conflict, even though he's hidden for most of the book, and even though he's working through Professor Quirrell. All right, so he is our top of the hierarchy main antagonist. Then underneath that, we have characters like Malfoy, Snape, and the Dursleys that create other kinds of conflict in Harry's day-to-day life. So, Malfoy, as you know, he's a rival at school. Snape is a teacher who makes Harry's life difficult and miserable in class. And the Dursleys make his quote-unquote home life at Privet Drive really miserable. Right. So all these characters definitely matter and they're definitely important to the story, but their conflicts don't carry the same weight as the struggle to keep the sorcerer's stone out of Voldemort's hands. And if you're familiar with this example, then you'll know that in the story, Malfoy shows up far more often than Voldemort does. But Voldemort is the one whose plan Harry has to stop at the climax, right? So he is the main antagonist. Okay, so I'm saying that because if you're struggling to figure out who is your main antagonist, then you can always think about what is your character going to be doing at the climax of your story and then work backwards from there because whatever is being wrapped up at your climax is probably your central conflict. Okay, so again, step one, we just wanted to separate our conflict out from our antagonist. And then step two is we want to establish your antagonist hierarchy. Once you've done those two things, then the question becomes okay, I've kind of labeled everyone where they belong. Now what do I do? How do I make these characters work together in my story to create a cohesive whole, right? And usually there's a concern of I don't want my plot to get pulled in 20 different directions, which is a totally valid concern. So how do we make multiple antagonists work? Well, the first
Give Each Antagonist a Clear Goal and Motivation
SPEAKER_00thing you want to do is give each antagonist, wherever they sit on your hierarchy, you want to give each of them a clear goal and a clear motivation. Because just like your protagonist, every antagonist in your story needs to want something and have a believable reason for wanting it. And the reason this is important is because their goals and their motivations are going to shape the choices they make, the actions they take, and the conflict they create for your protagonist. So again, just to go back to Harry Potter, think about the characters, right? Voldemort wants the sorcerer stone because he believes it's going to help him regain his physical form and make him immortal. Malfoy wants to prove basically that he's better than Harry and that he is superior in all ways, especially after Harry turns down his offer of friendship on the train in the very beginning. And then, of course, Snape and the Dursleys have their own goals and motivations that we don't need to go into, but you can probably imagine. All right, so either way, these characters, these antagonists, their motivations lead them to oppose Harry in different ways, right? Voldemort uses Quirl to help him steal the stone. And Malfoy, who's kind of on the opposite end of the spectrum, he looks for any opportunity to embarrass Harry or undermine Harry or get him in trouble while they're at school together. All right, so just an example. And a question I get asked when I talk about this a lot is like, how do I know how much development each character gets? Well, your main antagonist is going to need the most development, right? Because they are your main antagonist and they're responsible for the central conflict. I'm going to link to an episode that I did on five questions to help you develop your main antagonist in the show notes if you want to go deeper into that. But just remember that your main antagonist needs the most development and your lesser antagonist, you know, I would still encourage you to develop them with clear goals and motivations. But you might not need to go into everyone's backstory or know what everyone's family looks like and things like that. So just use your best judgment, but make sure you do flesh out your primary antagonist as fully as your protagonist. All right, so that is the first thing to think about. The second
Consider What Each Antagonist Contributes to Your Story
SPEAKER_00thing to think about is what each antagonist is going to contribute to your story. Because if you think about it, the purpose of having multiple antagonists isn't just to give your protagonist more problems to deal with. I mean, sometimes that's how it starts, but the actual purpose is to create different kinds of conflict and opposition that help your character grow and change and that add something meaningful to the bigger story that you're telling. So, what do I mean by this? Well, think about Harry Potter, right? Malfoy's rivalry with Harry creates a kind of social pressure and like day-to-day, kid-to-kid conflict at school. But it also helps reveal Harry's values to readers, particularly when it comes to friendship, loyalty, and how people treat others, right? And then if you think about someone like Snape, it's a little different, right? His hostility and his um, you know, just the way he is creates a different kind of conflict and tension. And as a teacher, he has authority over Harry, which is different than Malfoy. And we all know that Snape's suspicious behavior adds a lot of mystery and uncertainty around who is trying to steal the sorcerer's stone. So he is the red herring in this book and definitely serves a bigger purpose than, you know, just showing up to create conflict in this book and over the course of the series. All right, and then if you think about the Dursleys, whether that's like in the opening couple chapters or in the very end when Harry goes back to their house, their treatment of Harry creates a different kind of conflict, right? And it helps show readers how miserable Harry's time is when he's not at school. And that's what makes his friendships and the sense of acceptance that he finds at Hogwarts all the more meaningful. So we have multidimensional and multi-layered conflict, which makes the story really impactful. Now, what I want you to notice about this example while we're talking about it is that these characters aren't just creating different obstacles for Harry to overcome for no reason, right? They are contributing to his characterization, to his relationships, to the bigger theme, to the central conflict, and even how readers experience the story. Okay. So I know that's a lot easier to see in a draft that's finished, but your antagonist can serve similar purposes or have a similar effect on your story and on the reader. For example, one might interfere directly with your protagonist's main goal, while maybe others create pressure at home, at work, or in the relationships. You might even have some that challenge your protagonist's outdated beliefs or highlight their flaws or help you explore a theme or create suspense and uncertainty for readers. So really the options are kind of endless, and the way that you combine these things are kind of endless as well, which is kind of cool. But the important thing I want to highlight here is that each of your antagonists need to have a meaningful role in the larger story. Okay. Now, this doesn't mean that every antagonist needs to be 100% directly involved in your main plot or that their contributions can't overlap because sometimes they will and sometimes they do. But it's worth asking yourself for every antagonist you have, what would you lose if you removed that character from your story? And if you have a specific answer, then that's great. That means that you're probably on the right track and you can keep everybody. But if let's say you have two characters that are creating essentially the same kind of conflict and are serving the same bigger purpose in your story, then you might be able to combine them into a single character or cut one of them if they truly do seem a little bit unnecessary. All right, so that's the second thing you want to think about is what each antagonist is going to contribute to your story.
Consider How Each Antagonist's Conflict Will Unfold
SPEAKER_00And then the third thing is you'll want to think about how the conflict they create or how that plot thread will unfold over the course of the story. So we want to think about how does it unfold, and then also how do you make sure that all the different conflicts that are unfolding contribute to one cohesive story. Now, what I want to say up front here is that not every secondary antagonist needs a complete separate subplot or the same amount of pages or page time from beginning to end. You might have some that create conflict through your entire novel, like let's say you have a parent who is present in your character's life from page one and they're present the entire time creating conflict. And others might only become important during certain parts of the story. So, for example, you might have a character that you're introducing for the first time in act two, like let's say your character goes to a new school and they meet a new everyday bully, right? That character might only be relevant and causing conflict from act two on. And you can see this really clearly in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer Stone as well. So of course the Dursleys are really prominent in the beginning before Harry leaves for school and at the end when he comes back home, right? And then once Harry's at school, he has more conflicts with Malfoy and Snape, and those relationships and conflict come more into focus. And then meanwhile, the bigger threat involving Voldemort gradually comes into focus, and some of those secondary conflicts start to intersect with that primary conflict. So what I mean by that is remember the part where Malfoy discovers that Hagrid is hiding a baby dragon that he just hatched. And he knows that Harry and the other kids are trying to help relocate the dragon. So he tries to get Harry in trouble, right? He tells Filch, the school caretaker, that the kids are going to be in this certain place at a certain time, hoping to get them in trouble. And so what ends up happening is Harry and Malfoy are caught being out of bed after curfew, and they end up serving detention together in the Forbidden Forest, where, as you probably know, Harry encounters a mysterious hooded figure who is drinking unicorn blood, which is Voldemort. So as the story gets closer and closer to the climax, the threads of each antagonist's stories are intersecting more and more and causing complications for each other, if that makes sense. You can also see how that plays out with Harry being suspicious of Snape, because as long as he's suspicious of Snape, he's looking in the wrong direction and totally ignoring Professor Quirl, who is working on Voldemort's behalf, right? So you can use your secondary antagonist in so many different ways. And the other thing I want to bring up here about this example is that the conflicts Harry faces and the antagonists Harry has to deal with, they don't all play out in the same way and they don't all reach their conclusion at the same time. So by the end of the novel, Voldemort's immediate plans have been stopped, right? He does not get the sorcerer's stone. But Malfoy is still Harry's rival going into book two and beyond, and Snape is still his teacher in book two and beyond. And Voldemort himself actually remains a threat, obviously, for the entire series. So the plot of book one is closed out, and Harry has defeated the antagonist in book one, but obviously that is a book series, so the conflict has to continue. So if you're writing a series, the reason I want to say this is if you're writing a series, your novel's central conflict needs a satisfying resolution, but not every secondary antagonist needs to be fully defeated or have their conflict with your protagonist fully resolved. Some conflicts might reach a conclusion earlier in the story, and others might change as your protagonist grows or continue beyond the end of your novel. Again, if you are writing a series. All right, but the key point either way is that we want the conflicts created by your antagonist, whether they're primary or secondary, we want them to feel like a meaningful part of your protagonist's journey rather than unrelated problems that appear and disappear without consequence. Okay, so you'll just want to think about how does each antagonist's conflict unfold and then also how do they play together, right? And once you do that, you should have a lot of brainstorming notes and a lot of ideas for how you can actually tackle a novel with multiple antagonists. So back to the main question of the episode: can your novel have more than one antagonist? Absolutely, it can, but the goal isn't to just give your protagonist as many enemies as possible in the hopes that that will make your story really interesting. Instead, the goal is to make sure the antagonists that you include have a meaningful role to play in the bigger picture of the story and that the conflict they create contributes to the bigger picture and that bigger story you're telling.
Final Thoughts & Free Training Invitation
SPEAKER_00All right, so just to quickly recap what we talked about, we talked about the difference between antagonists and conflict and how antagonists create conflict and are one source of conflict, but just because something creates conflict doesn't mean it's an antagonist. Okay, so those are two different things. We talked about how to establish your antagonist hierarchy. So who is your main antagonist and who are your secondary antagonists? And then we talked about how to make multiple antagonists work in your novel. So first you want to give each antagonist a clear goal and motivation. Then you want to consider what each antagonist contributes to the bigger story or how their conflict is going to contribute to the bigger story. And then lastly, we talked about how each antagonist's conflict will unfold, as well as how that conflict is going to kind of work with or play with the other conflicts that are unfolding at the same time. Now, that being said, antagonists are only one part of a story, right? You still need to develop your protagonists, their goals, the stakes, the central conflict that drives your plot, and so many other things. And what I see a lot is that writers will have ideas for each of these elements, and that's a great start for sure. But a lot of people run into problems developing them into a story that works. So if this is you and if you're stuck or struggling to turn your ideas into a finished draft, then I want you to go check out my free training called Why You Keep Getting Stuck and How to Finally Finish Your Novel. In that training, I'll show you what goes into developing a strong foundation for your story. I'll talk about why that foundational work matters and why when you do it matters, as well as how it can help you make progress towards finally finishing your draft. So again, that is my free training. It's called Why You Keep Getting Stuck and How to Finally Finish Your Novel. And we will put a link to that in the show notes if you want to come check it out. And that is all I have for you in this episode. So as always, thank you so much for tuning in. I hope your writing is going really well, and I will see you next week.